Posted: Jan 31, 2014 1:43 PM by Megan Schultz, KOMU 8 Reporter
Updated: Sep 12, 2014 5:28 PM
JEFFERSON CITY - The Missouri House and the Missouri Senate have introduced similar legislation that would extend more privacy rights to Missourians.
Missouri State Senator Rob Schaaf introduced to a Senate committee an amendment to the Missouri constitution that would add electronics to the Unreasonable Search and Seizure clause. Republican House Member Robert Cornejo introduced a bill that would require a search warrant specifically for location information on an electronic device.
This comes a few months after Edward Snowden leaked information that had many Americans feeling their privacy had been violated, especially in the use of cell phones. Both Schaaf and Cornejo said they introduced their legislation in response to the NSA controversy.
Right now, the Missouri constitution protects people from unreasonable search and seizures from "persons, papers, homes and effects." This means that in order to access any of these criteria, any government entity must get a search warrant from a judge after proving "probable cause."
Schaaf said the proposed amendment is to protect Missourians at both the local and state level.
"Let's say you get arrested and they have your cell phone, they can look on your cell phone , you know, without a warrant. That's wrong," Schaaf said. "They should have to have a warrant. Most people consider their cell phone to be sort of like their briefcase, an extension of their papers. But, that's not what the constitution says. The constitution was written long before there was electronics communications and data."
But, when KOMU 8 asked people about the proposed amendment, some mentioned car safety. If, for instance, someone gets in a car crash, a police officer on the scene can search the phone's contacts for an emergency contact, such as a spouse or parent.
"If you're unconscious and unable to speak and we want to notify, you know, a relative or something, we can look in your phone and do that notification," said Columbia Police Sgt. Joe Bernhard.
But, responding officers may not be able to do this on the scene if they have to obtain a search warrant.
Columbia Police and Highway Patrol said they aren't allowed to comment on specific legislation.
When KOMU 8 asked Schaaf's office what implications such an amendment would have on the car wreck situation, however, they said this problem wasn't the purpose of the bill and although they didn't mention any specifics, suggested a possible exception to the rule during emergencies.
Bernhard also said that the Columbia Police is ahead of the trend because officers already obtain search warrants when conducting investigations, even though it's not required by the constitution yet. If there is reason to believe that someone was texting or on the phone seconds before a major crash, for example, the police can seize the phone and obtain a search warrant to look through the phone history.
"We routinely get search warrants for anything electronic, computers thing like that," said Bernhard. "It just makes the whole investigation cleaner and stand up in court, there's no question later on whether you followed the evidence or not. If you have a search warrant from a judge, pretty much, that's going to get in the court."
But, the amendment could also have national implications.
Senator Schaaf says Missouri is the first state to propose this type of amendment to a state constitution, but he hopes to inspire other states to do the same.
"Well see my goal is to create a national debate," said Schaaf. "I don't think the bill would do a whole lot in Missouri, but if there's an overwhelming vote for it, which I think there would be, then it would certainly stir a national debate."
If other states adopted such an amendment, this may spark the federal government to consider its own amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
But, MU political science professor Paul Wallace, who teaches a course about terrorism, says this amendment could have major implications for national security.
"It's central to national security because one of the major considerations now in terms of national security is that a tradeoff between security and privacy," said Wallace. "And this is being argued on the national level in Congress all the time. Wednesday, James Clapper, head of the National Intelligence Agency, testified before a Senate Committee and he point blankely said that cyber terrorism is the number one problem for the U.S. This is the second year he's identified cyber terrorism as the number one concern for homeland security."
In regards to this tradeoff, more privacy with unreasonable search and seziure of electronics could mean less security, especially, Wallace says, if obtaining a search warrant takes time that could be precious in the midst of a terrorist threat.
But, he says he agrees with the amendment, saying he values protection, especially from the NSA.
The Senate floor is expected to vote on the amendment next week, and the House bill is in committee. If both the Senate and House pass the amendment, voters will vote on the issue in November.
Posted 5:25 PM 11/29/2015 by The Associated Press
STEWARTSVILLE (AP) - A northwest Missouri man is dead after pointing a weapon at law enforcement officers who were responding to a domestic disturbance.
The Missouri State Highway Patrol says the patrol and Dekalb County Sheriff's Department responded to a call near Stewartsville at 10:18 (More)
Posted 4:16 PM 11/29/2015 by Eric Yount, KOMU 8 Digital Producer
COLUMBIA - Columbia police arrested a man who allegedly grabbed a 14-year-old relative by the hair for not wearing a hijab, a traditional Muslim headscarf.
The incident occurred on Tuesday at Hickman High School shortly before school was to let out for the day. Police say (More)
Posted 3:02 PM 11/29/2015 by James Packard, KOMU 8 Reporter
COLUMBIA - As the post-Thanksgiving shopping weekend winds down, Columbia small businesses were preparing Sunday for a rush of online shopping, largely dominated by big-name retailers, during Cyber Monday.
The National Retail Federation (NRF) says it created the term "Cyber Monday" in 2005 (More)
Posted 1:47 PM 11/29/2015 by The Associated Press
JOPLIN (AP) — A southwest Missouri newspaper's recent attempts to obtain emails from three former public officials in Joplin resulted in two denials because the records were wiped clean soon after the leaders left office.
The Joplin Globe, which requested the records, reports (More)
Adv. - more news below
Posted 1:38 PM 11/29/2015 by Alex Farkas, KOMU 8 Reporter
COLUMBIA - Sunday marks the 11th annual Drive Safer Sunday on the year's busiest day of travel.
Non-profit organization Road Safe America (RSA) is reminding drivers to be safe on the roads during the holidays including not only Thanksgiving, but also the upcoming Christmas and New Year's (More)
Posted 1:30 PM 11/29/2015 by The Associated Press
SILEX (AP) — The mayor of a tiny eastern Missouri town is dead after being involved in a head-on collision with a vehicle that crossed the center line.
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports 67-year-old David E. Rice of Silex was pronounced dead Friday at a St. Louis-area (More)
Posted 11:31 AM 11/29/2015 by Associated Press
NORMANDY (AP) — It's been more than 15 months since Michael Brown became a household name after a white police officer shot and killed the black 18-year-old in the St. Louis suburb of Ferguson.
But Brown's fame stands in stark contrast to the relative obscurity of his (More)
Posted 6:52 PM 11/28/2015 by The Associated Press
JEFFERSON CITY (AP) - Missouri lawmakers are set to question officials in Gov. Jay Nixon's administration on how the state spends money to help refugees.
The Legislature recently set the Monday hearing in response to deadly attacks in Paris and criticism of Nixon's decision not to (More)
Adv. - more news below
Posted 4:38 PM 11/28/2015 by Emma Balkenbush, KOMU 8 Reporter
JEFFERSON CITY - Natasha Johnson started the group, Show Me-Just and Caring Communities, in 2013 and is now beginning to develop the group further.
Johnson started the anti-bully group with another parent after learning about a middle school student who had committed suicide after (More)