TARGET 8 fact checks Eric Greitens' attack ad on Chris Koster
COLUMBIA - KOMU 8's Target 8 Investigative team analyzed a negative advertisement about Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster (D), who is running for Governor for Missouri. The ad, paid for by his challenger, Eric Greitens (R), claimed Koster wants to expand the Affordable Care Act by billions in Missouri. The ad stated "Obamacare" is “threatening to bankrupt states like Colorado and Illinois."
Each statement is labeled as true, false, or incomplete based on Target 8's investigation.
'Chris Koster supports Obamacare. Chris Koster wants to expand Obamacare by billions here in Missouri.': TRUE
In a written statement, Policy Director for Eric Greitens Will Scharf said the claim of expanding the ACA by billions came from the cost per person covered by the Medicaid Expansion multiplied by projected size of expansion in Missouri.
"The projected size of the Obamacare Medicaid Expansion population in Missouri is 452,000. Thus, a reasonable estimate for an annual cost of the Medicaid Expansion in Missouri is $2.88 billion," Scharf wrote to the Target 8 team in an email.
On Koster's campaign website under the "issues" portion, Koster laid out his plan to expand Medicaid in Missouri to 300,000 working Missourians.
The word choice on this claim can be confusing because Medicaid is only one part of the ACA. Vice President of Health Policy for Missouri Foundation for Health (which supports expansion) Ryan Barker said the ad confuses two different parts of the Affordable Care Act.
“The ACA is a large piece of legislation. There’s lots of different components. The components that are about insurance rules, regulations and what employers have to offer in their insurance plans, that is a completely different component than the Medicaid expansion part," Barker said. "So the ad sort of conflates these different parts of the ACA and tries to say they’re related, and they're really sort of separate parts.”
Overall, the ad does indicate Koster would expand the ACA, which is true, though the language is vague.
Obamacare expansion is not only ruining health care and hurting businesses like this, it’s threatening to bankrupt states like Colorado and Illinois: INCOMPLETE
Greitens' campaign sourced expert commentary that blames overruns in enrollment and costs as the reason for Colorado and Illinois' strained budget.
Barker said Missouri's Medicaid plan shouldn't be compared to Colorado and Illinois in terms of Medicaid expansion.
“Every state the program is slightly different in terms of eligibility levels and what income levels are, so it’s really hard to make comparisons,” Barker said. "What’s interesting is the two states, Colorado and Illinois, that were picked in the ad, are two states that had higher eligibility to start with so their expansion isn’t as expansive as Missouri’s would be.”
Barker said higher premiums on health care insurance could hurt some business who offer employers simple plans, but Medicaid expansion could have a varying impact on businesses overall.
"It’s a real mixed bag in terms of finding examples of employers that saw health care costs go up a whole lot, and you can find examples of employers that saw a lot of cost savings because of the Affordable Care Act. Trying to relate that to the Medicaid expansion, the cost to savings or employers, is a different part of the Affordable Care Act.”
In 2012 the Supreme Court made Medicaid expansion in the Affordable Care Act optional to states. So far Missouri has not expanded Medicaid.
This claim included opinionated language and comparisons that cannot be fully proven out or projected, so Target 8 deems this claim incomplete.
Koster weighs in
During a campaign event on Saturday, Koster clarified his position on the ACA to a KOMU 8 reporter: