Your View

Your View: Viewers Question Coverage of Moberly High School Lunch Situation

Posted: Apr 12, 2013 9:01 PM by Nick Brennan & Scott Malone
Updated: May 7, 2013 9:56 PM

Rating: 0.0 (0 votes)

MOBERLY - In recent weeks, some viewers have said on Facebook that KOMU 8 News did not effectively cover the story of Moberly High School staff allegedly taking away students' lunches if the students owed lunch money to the school.

Specifically, viewers want to know why the story did not include an official statement from the school or the school district. Nick Barnett commented on Facebook, saying, "Did you ever think to talk to Moberly Schools before you blast this out like you are? I know they weren't available Friday, so call them Monday. Pretty hard to get a good story with just one side of it."

KOMU 8's reporter Matt Evans explained his attempts to get a comment from the school and the district. "I say ‘I'd love to talk to you, let's sit down, you're the principal, you're the leader of this school, I'm sure you have insight into this.' He says he couldn't talk until he got permission from the superintendent.

"I asked if I could call the superintendent. He said he would. He called her and texted her. Never heard back from her. He stayed around for probably another 20 or 30 minutes while I shot video of the school, and then left."

MU Journalism Management Professor Mike Dunn said he would have run the story even without a true comment from the school or the district. "I would've still run the story. It may be true when the principal says I can't comment until the superintendent tells me I can comment, but that seems to be an inefficient way of doing things.

"Again: if I were looking at management structure, people who report to me, I tell them, ‘You have responsibility, you can take charge of things in my absence up to a certain point."

Another viewer, Corey Harding, said KOMU 8's student staff left out a major aspect of the story, and called the report incomplete and exaggerated. "I know you've been taught in school that a good report touches on all the major facets of a particular issue.

"The district's reaction/comment/statement is a major facet of this story, yet it was left off so the story could run incompletely. Not only is this sensationalism, it's crap reporting."

MU Journalism Professor Charles Davis explained the amount of time to wait for a statement from the school or the district truly depends on the story. "Clearly, this is not Watergate. This is a lunch dust-up in Moberly with the schools, so I'm not going to hold the story very long on a non-response.

"And I think the station probably made the right call by going on the air if the guy was pretty adamant about refusing to go on. If this story were about a waste, fraud, abuse, corruption and it started moving up the scale of severity then the further that moves up the scale, the longer you're going to wait."

"If [the school or the district] would have talked to us, the story could have been crafted in a different way," Evans said. "But he refused to. So I gave them as much time and benefit of the doubt as I could, and I even included the letter that we got from a viewer, from the school's point of view.

"So even if the school didn't talk to us, I still got that side. Even if it wasn't directly from the district, it was from a parent in that email that they sent out. So I used that in both my on-air story and my web version.

Dunn said he would like to give the school a chance to make a statement in a follow-up story, and to provide an explanation for parents and viewers.. "I know they said that this [incident] is not going to happen again. But give me an explanation. What did you put into place that means that it won't reoccur? And I would give the principal a chance to do that, or the superintendent. Whichever one is willing to speak on the record."

What do you think? Do you think KOMU accurately covered the Moberly school lunch incident? Let us know on Facebook, Twitter, or Google Plus. Then watch Friday nights at 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. as we report "Your View" of the news.

  • News

    Sparta police chief on leave after dog shot

    Sparta police chief on leave after dog shot

    Posted 6:56 AM 11/26/2015 by The Associated Press

    SPARTA (AP) - A southwest Missouri police chief has been placed on leave after killing a pit bull.

    The Springfield News-Leader reports that Sparta Police Chief Andrew Spencer was placed on leave Tuesday.

    A police report says a resident told Spencer earlier this month that (More)

  • News

    Bondswoman dies after exchanging gunfire with authorities

    Bondswoman dies after exchanging gunfire with authorities

    Posted 5:40 AM 11/26/2015 by The Associated Press

    OZARK (AP) - A Missouri woman has been found dead after shooting at bail bondsmen and exchanging gunfire with law enforcement.

    Sgt. Jason Pace, of the Missouri State Highway Patrol, identified the woman killed Wednesday afternoon as Somer Brook Speer, of Ozark. She also is a bondwoman (More)

  • News

    Hundreds expected to receive meals in Thanksgiving tradition

    Hundreds expected to receive meals in Thanksgiving tradition

    Posted 5:37 AM 11/26/2015 by Eric Yount, KOMU 8 Reporter

    COLUMBIA - Dozens of turkeys were cooked Wednesday in preparation for a community meal Thanksgiving day.

    This marks the 18th year of Almeta Crayton's Community Programs "Everybody Eats."  A full Thanksgiving meal will be available to guests at Stamper Commons on the Stephens College (More)

  • News

    Mission Drive developers ask for help funding road expansion

    Posted 6:14 PM 11/25/2015 by Taylor Stevens, KOMU 8 Reporter

    JEFFERSON CITY - The developers of a proposed shopping center off of Mission Drive asked the Cole County Commission for $800,000 to extend the road to the site. The Harvard Company, LLC is working to develop a site near Highway 179 that would include restaurants and retail stores among other (More)

  • Adv. - more news below

  • Target 8

    TARGET 8: School closings stay consistent with snow data

    Posted 1:08 PM 11/3/2015 by Collin Ruane & Emma Nicolas, KOMU 8 Reporters

    BOONVILLE - It's almost that time of year again. Students across mid-Missouri will anxiously wait to see if they get any snow days this school year. But are students getting more days off for less snow?

    To find the answer to that question, KOMU 8 News went through more than a decade worth (More)

  • News

    Organization wants Missourians to "can the grease"

    Posted 12:02 PM 11/25/2015 by Steve Dawson, KOMU 8 Reporter

    COLUMBIA - Cooking grease can cost homeowners money if it's improperly disposed of.

    This holiday season, Missouri American Water is launching a state-wide campaign to "can the grease."

    Instead of pouring cooking grease down the drain, the organization urged residents to put used (More)

  • News

    Community rebuilds after arson fire damages downtown businesses

    Community rebuilds after arson fire damages downtown businesses

    Posted 3:49 PM 11/25/2015 by Ashton Day, KOMU 8 Digital Producer

    MOBERLY - A Moberly clothing store held its grand reopening Wednesday night, two weeks after a fire damaged its previous building.

    The Nov. 7 arson fire caused extensive smoke damage to Encore, a women's clothing shop.

    Two other businesses closed due to the fire. Duval (More)

  • News

    Columbia Tribune Black Friday edition "too big," causes delay

    Posted 1:53 PM 11/25/2015 by Ashton Day, KOMU 8 Digital Producer

    COLUMBIA – The Columbia Daily Tribune announced on its website Wednesday that it’s Black Friday edition was too big.

    The large amount of Black Friday ads prevented the Tribune from being able to package through its inserting equipment. Staff members had to package the paper by (More)

  • Adv. - more news below

  • News

    Judge hears testimony in case of St. Louis Zoo gun ban

    Judge hears testimony in case of St. Louis Zoo gun ban

    Posted 1:51 PM 11/25/2015 by The Associated Press

    ST. LOUIS (AP) — A judge heard testimony as he considers lifting the St. Louis Zoo policy that prohibits patrons from entering the zoo with guns.

    The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports that St. Louis Circuit Judge Joan Moriarty issued a temporary order on June 12 upholding the ban (More)

  • News

    MU for Planned Parenthood hopes Foley responds before deadline

    Posted 1:48 PM 11/25/2015 by Annisa Budiman, KOMU 8 Reporter

    COLUMBIA – Mizzou students in support for Planned Parenthood are struggling to start a conversation with MU Interim Chancellor Hank Foley on the decision for Planned Parenthood to stop providing safe abortions.

    Jordan Hoyt, a member of the group, said their effort to schedule (More)

KOMU First Alert Weather

Most Popular Right Now

Select a station to view its upcoming show schedule: KOMU 8 CW Mid-Missouri's CW

Coming Up Next

7:00 amToday
9:00 amThe 89th Annual Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade
12:00 pmThe National Dog Show

Tonight's Schedule

7:00 pmFootball Night in America
7:30 pmNFL on Thanksgiving

Coming Up Next

8:00 amThe Steve Wilkos Show
9:00 amThe Steve Wilkos Show
10:00 amCrazy Talk

Tonight's Schedule

7:00 pmWhose Line Is It Anyway?
7:30 pmWhose Line Is It Anyway?
8:00 pmWhose Line Is It Anyway?
8:30 pmWhose Line Is It Anyway?
9:00 pmKOMU 8 News @ Nine on The CW
9:30 pmSeinfeld