Dortch was found guilty on charges of first degree murder following the fatal shooting that occured in Douglass Park. Dortch was also sentenced to 15 years in prison on a charge of armed criminal action.

In a written statement given to the judge, Dortch claimed ineffective counsel. Attorney David Wallace told the judge that Dortch's conviction would be appealed and that he plans to file a motion for a new trial.

During Dortch's trial the defense team tried to convince the jurors that Dortch acted in self defense during the time of the shooting.