Federal court cracks down on cage-free egg claims

3 years 6 months 2 weeks ago Wednesday, March 08 2017 Mar 8, 2017 Wednesday, March 08, 2017 9:53:00 AM CST March 08, 2017 in News
By: Nora Faris, KOMU 8 Reporter
loading

CENTRALIA - Cage-free, free range, all natural, organic, conventional—what do the scramble of labels on egg cartons really mean? 

According to a federal court, not what consumers think they do.

In a decision released in late February by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, the court determined cage-free eggs are not more nutritious and do not carry a lower risk of Salmonella contamination than eggs from caged hens.

Animal rights groups Compassion Over Killing and the Animal Legal Defense Fund made those claims in a lawsuit, calling for mandatory egg carton labels disclosing production practices, like the use of cages to house laying hens.

The plaintiffs said egg companies mislead consumers by using labels, marketing slogans and brand names that evoke pastoral images of hens raised outdoors, when they actually raise the birds indoors in cages.  

Defendents in the case included the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the Food and Drug Administration and the Federal Trade Commission, each of which exercises some oversight of food product labeling.

Although the court ruling denied that cage-free eggs are safer or more nutritious, some consumers and animal advocates say cage-free designations are still an indicator of better animal welfare.

Cage-free hens are often still raised indoors, but they are generally given more space to roost and roam and, like the name implies, are not confined to cages.

Jo Manhart of the Missouri Egg Council said production labels still don't indicate the most important factor in animal welfare: farm management.

"You can have poorly raised cage-free and superbly raised conventional birds, poorly raised backyard flocks and absolutely excellent backyard farms," Manhart said. "The clue is in the management, and the label doesn't really tell you that."

McDonald's, Walmart and a host of the nation's largest food and grocery businesses have announced commitments to source only cage-free eggs by 2025.

Now, U.S. egg producers must scramble to meet the expected spike in cage-free egg demand. Converting conventional operations to cage-free systems is expected to cost farmers up to $10 billion. In total, the U.S. egg industry is valued at $10 billion per year.

Dustin Stanton, operator of Stanton Brothers Eggs in Centralia, said he chose to begin his cage-free farm to fill a niche, consumer-driven market. 

He said he sees a place for both cage-free and conventional operations in the marketplace.

"We have to be very careful in the choices we make so we can feed the rest of the world, too," Stanton said. "We are the breadbasket for the world. As a whole, I think it should be left to consumers' choice. The farmers and producers should be able to do what they want to do, and then when we get to the store, have the consumers choose what they want."

Consumers pay a premium for cage-free eggs. On average, cage-free eggs cost $1 to $2 more per dozen than eggs from caged hens.

 

More News

Grid
List
COLUMBIA – Mizzou's football fans are reconciling their team spirit with a global pandemic. The Tigers met Alabama at... More >>
10 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 7:57:00 PM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
HALLSVILLE – With the 2020 election fast approaching, a few Missouri politicians tried to sell themselves, from a cell. ... More >>
13 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 4:59:00 PM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
(CNN) -- President Donald Trump on Saturday said he is nominating Amy Coney Barrett , a conservative federal appeals court... More >>
14 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 4:20:23 PM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - Today marked the 20th anniversary of Jefferson City’s Oktoberfest and while there were doubts over whether or... More >>
15 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 3:09:00 PM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia Public School's Dr. Peter Stiepleman was named 2021 Superintendent of the Year by Missouri Association of School... More >>
16 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 2:06:00 PM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
As COVID-19 continues to spread, KOMU 8 will continue to update you about impacts in the community. Previous coverage: ... More >>
20 hours ago Saturday, September 26 2020 Sep 26, 2020 Saturday, September 26, 2020 10:09:00 AM CDT September 26, 2020 in News
STE. GENEVIEVE - Blair Oaks' 51 regular season game win streak ended against Valle Catholic on Friday. Blair Oaks fell... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 8:47:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in Friday Night Fever
(CNN) -- Covid-19 vaccinations could start as early as November, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the nation's leading infectious disease expert, said... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 7:55:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia’s Goodwill Excel Center Hosted its very first commencement ceremony. The Goodwill Excel Center is a free... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 7:51:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
JEFFERSON CITY (AP) — Nine television stations have pulled an ad criticizing Democratic candidate for Missouri governor Nicole Galloway. ... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 5:47:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
MID-MISSOURI - Week five of Friday Night Fever is here. Before you head out to your team's game or tune... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 5:42:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in Sports
O'FALLON, Mo. (AP) — A federal appeals court panel is weighing the fate of a sweeping Missouri abortion law, including... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 5:15:01 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
Welcome to Week 5 of Friday Night Fever! Our game of the week features the Eldon Mustangs travelling to Southern... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 4:55:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in Friday Night Fever
Below are scores from high school football games from across mid-Missouri. Check out KOMU 8's liveblog with updates from some... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 4:54:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in Friday Night Fever
ASHLAND - It's Thursday morning. Head football coach Trent Tracy gets to Southern Boone High School to turn on the... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 4:10:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in Friday Night Fever
MOUNT VERNON, Mo. (AP) — Nine people have been indicted by a grand jury in connection with the kidnapping and... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 4:05:38 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
(CNN) -- President Donald Trump intends to choose Amy Coney Barrett to be the new Supreme Court justice, according to... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 3:16:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - Jefferson City firefighters responded to a structure fire in the 400 block of Marshall Street Friday morning... More >>
1 day ago Friday, September 25 2020 Sep 25, 2020 Friday, September 25, 2020 12:12:00 PM CDT September 25, 2020 in News
Columbia, MO
Broken Clouds 61°
7am 63°
8am 64°
9am 66°
10am 68°