Genetic testing - Helpful, not meant to replace professional analysis
COLUMBIA - 23andMe, a leader of at-home genetic testing, introduced the first over-the-counter breast cancer screening one year ago. Since then, there's been an ongoing debate about how useful the information from at-home tests is.
Fans of a home health test see it as a convenient, inexpensive way to give consumers direct access to information about their health history. For about $200, you're mailed a kit, spit into a vial, send it back to the company, then check online a few weeks later for results.
Critics say issues raised by over-the-counter genetic tests, like 23andMe, shouldn't be ignored.
Dr. Mark Vellek is a medical oncologist and hematologist at Missouri Cancer Associates. He warns against putting too much faith in over-the-counter tests.
"It doesn't test every patient correctly. And, you're missing a lot of other genes that could have an impact, they think, 'I'm negative, I don't have to do anything,'" Vellek said. "It gives them a false sense of security and really potentially put them in danger. It would miss a lot of the mutations we know about. There's more than 100 mutations for BRCA 1 and BRCA 2."
The Food and Drug Administration has cautioned consumers about over-the-counter genetic tests, warning, while they may provide some useful information, they are not meant to be a substitute for a comprehensive assessment from medical professionals.
Here is what you need to know about genetic testing if you're considering it.
DNA doesn't equal your destiny.
While a family history can contribute to the likelihood of you developing a disease, it's always caused by a mix of factors, including how healthy you are and the environment you live in. Your genetics is just one factor.
Medical professionals matter.
Tests your doctor order are far more comprehensive than those that can be bought over the counter. Doctors call for sequencing of entire genes and look for many variants that have been linked to a disease in question.
Dr. Mark Vellek says, "one of the things that revolutionized (genetic testing) is insurance is paying for it more easily. So the maximum out of pocket is about $250."
By comparison, 23andMe is between $170-$200 for the health and ancestry information.
Consider privacy protection.
The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 prohibits employers or health insurance companies from using your genetic information to make decisions. But, that law does not apply to long-term-care insurance, disability insurance or life insurance. Your genetic information - like a risk of early-onset Alzheimer's, or breast cancer - can potentially be used against you.
So far, 23andMe is the only company to be FDA approved for its over-the-counter genetic health risk test. This means the FDA finds the 23andMe screening is accurate and easy for consumers to understand. Dr. Vellek pointed out, "FDA approved" does not mean "clinically useful."
23andMe relies on much simpler technology than tests you'd get at the doctor's office and offers no genetic counseling to help you understand the results.
A doctor will usually refer you to a genetic counselor.
JEFFERSON CITY — The River City Habitat for Humanity housed more than 1 million nails over the weekend. Mid... More >>
COLUMBIA - The mother of one of the victims in Columbia's two weekend homicides described her daughter as "a really... More >>
To start this climate conversation, we have to begin somewhere. So, let's start with the basics: the diference between weather... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - Three people died in a crash Sunday afternoon in Cole County while a driver fled from police... More >>
BOONVILLE, Mo. (AP) — The family of a South Dakota woman who was found shot to death in Missouri last... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - Officers have taken a man into custody in relation to a shots fired incident on Sept. 3... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - Officers responded to reports of a car crashing into a home in the 900 block of Sardonyx... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - A truck crashed into the Ventura Townhome complex Saturday morning in relation to a domestic assault, according... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - The 4th annual Tunnel to Towers 5K was held at the Governor's Garden on Saturday. This... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY — The Jefferson City Police Department announced its participation in the National Child Passenger Safety Week enforcement campaign... More >>
NEW LEBANON - For one group, New Lebanon's bicentennial celebration was a unification decades in the making. While researching her... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — The percentage of successful disability cases aimed at reversing the denial or re-evaluation of benefits... More >>
COLUMBIA - The Columbia Police Department is investigating two homicides after three people were shot Friday night. Officers said... More >>
COLUMBIA - Below are scores from football games around mid-Missouri. Final scores are in bold. ... More >>
COLUMBIA - Columbia police and the city's Solid Waste Department will expand the search area in the Megan Shultz case.... More >>
JEFFERSON CITY - It's been nine months since Melissa Peskey's death, and the family together with the Missouri State Highway... More >>