Lawyer in case against police says court trying to limit First Amendment

1 year 5 months 1 week ago Friday, August 11 2017 Aug 11, 2017 Friday, August 11, 2017 4:16:00 PM CDT August 11, 2017 in News
By: Steve Lambson, KOMU 8 News Content Manager

COLUMBIA - An attorney for the plaintiff in a case related to filming police actions in public has filed a petition for a rehearing, after a ruling from the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis.

The original case involved Matt Akins, founder of a group called Citizens for Justice, and his actions to document police actions. Akins posted some of his videos on the Columbia Police Department's Facebook page, which videos he said were later removed. Akins further claimed police ordered him to "stop filming the filing of a citizen complaint in the CPD lobby." Akins alleged these actions by CPD violated his First Amendment rights.

After filing the suit, Akins and his lawyer, Stephen Wyse, filed a motion seeking a recusal from the case by Judge Nanette Laughrey, which Laughrey denied. She also denied a second recusal request, as well as a request to reconsider her decision to grant a motion to dismiss, filed by the defendants, which include members of both the police department and Boone County's prosecutor's office. Finally, Laughrey granted a motion by the defendants for summary judgement, or a decision without a trial, while denying Akins' request for partial summary judgement.

In early June, Akins turned to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis to consider his recusal requests. He claimed Laughrey should have recused herself for reasons including the following: Laughrey's husband is part of a mayoral task force for the City of Columbia, Akins had posted video in which he was critical specifically of Laughrey, his attorney had filed a complaint against Laughrey in the past, and Laughrey used to be a municipal judge in Columbia.

In response to Akins' petition, the appeals court panel found no legal justification for any of his claims and no reason why Laughrey should have been required to recuse herself. It also said in its ruling "we conclude that the district court did not err in its thorough and well reasoned opinions. Accordingly, we affirm."

Wyse said in a media release on Wednesday the appeals court, in affirming Laughrey's decision, stands by the district court's ruling that "neither the public nor the media has a First Amendment right to videotape, photograph, or make audio recordings of government proceedings that are by law open to the public.”

Wyse said further in his release, "The First Amendment is a core American value. The right to free speech and a free press are central to our liberty and our ability to hold our government accountable. This holding of the 8th Circuit undermines the basic rights of Missourians and the citizens of the six other 8th Circuit states and undermines the First Amendment rights for all Americans. I’ve asked the 8th Circuit to reconsider its ruling as a requirement for preparing our appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court."

In her ruling, Laughrey cited two cases. The first was Rice v. Kempker, a 2004 case between the Reverend Larry Rice, head of the New Life Evangelistic Center, and the Department of Corrections. In that case, Rice argued the Department of Corrections policy banning cameras from execution chambers violated the First Amendment right of public access. The court ruled in favor of the Department of Corrections, arguing any burden on constitutional access rights were legitimate because of concerns about the treatment of people convicted of crimes.

The second case was Wisconsin Interscholastic Athletic Association v. Gannett Company, Inc. In 2005, WIAA contracted a video production company to stream its athletic tournament events online. Newspapers with Gannett argued the license agreements violated First Amendment rights to broadcast the games. The court ruled in favor of WIAA.

In her decision related to Akins' case, Laughrey said the following: 

"Akins also argues that he was retaliated against when he was stopped from filming a citizen in the Police Department lobby in 2011; his links to the Citizens for Justice page were removed from the Police Department’s Facebook page in the summer of 2011; and he was excluded from a Police Department Media Training Day in October 2015. None of the individual Defendants participated in these incidents...Moreover, Akins points to no unconstitutional municipal policy or custom. Further, he has no constitutional right to videotape any public proceedings he wishes to. [Akins'] links to the Police Department’s Facebook page were treated the same as everyone else’s and there is no constitutional right to unlimited posting."

Laughrey continued by addressing Akins' claims he was illegally barred from a media training event held by CPD: "Finally, with respect to the media training event, Akins was not a member of the traditional media, nor does the record show he was an active nontraditional media member at the time. Space was limited. These were content-neutral reasons not to create an exception for Akins to attend the invitation-only event. The media does not enjoy a right of equal access or special First Amendment rights."

For this reasoning Laughrey cited Snyder v. Ringgold, a case out of Baltimore dealing with the question of whether reporters have equal right to exclusive stories, specific interviews, or off-the-record statements. The court in this case ruled they do not have that equal right.

Professor Sandy Davidson, who teaches communication law at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, said key questions include what exactly falls under the defition of a "government proceeding" and what is permissible or legal versus what is a First Amendment right. For example, courts and judges can limit media access to trial proceedings while still allowing the public to attend, and the U.S. Supreme Court does not allow cameras in its proceedings. Where police actions in public places fall in the larger area of public government activity has not been made clear by the court.

(Editor's note: this story has been updated to include insight from Professor Sandy Davidson from the University of Missouri School of Journalism)

More News

Grid
List
HOLTS SUMMIT - A woman displaced by a massive fire in Holts Summit Monday said it was "horrific and real."... More >>
29 minutes ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 4:16:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA – A recently-published pilot study by an MU law professor calls attention to landlords’ sexual harassment of their low-income... More >>
36 minutes ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 4:09:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - A recent report says Missouri ranks 49th in average starting teacher salary. The Missouri Department of Elementary... More >>
1 hour ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 3:22:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
CLIFTON HILL - The Westran School District released its students from class early Tuesday due to a water main break... More >>
1 hour ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 2:57:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - A former Jefferson City Public Schools employee filed a lawsuit accusing the district of discrimination. Denise... More >>
1 hour ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 2:51:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - House Democrats want more funding for K-12 transportation and the Columbia School Board agrees. “Desperately underfunded,"... More >>
2 hours ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 2:45:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - The Harry S. Truman Memorial Veterans' Hospital has been awarded the Veterans Health Administration's award for "Best Place... More >>
2 hours ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 2:39:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - The largest rural transit provider in the state is reducing services because of the government shutdown. “What... More >>
2 hours ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 2:31:00 PM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Firefighters said unattended cooking caused the fire at an apartment complex in central Columbia on Sunday. The... More >>
6 hours ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 10:25:00 AM CST January 22, 2019 in News
MONITEAU COUNTY - Moniteau County deputies are looking for a man from the city of California after they said he... More >>
6 hours ago Tuesday, January 22 2019 Jan 22, 2019 Tuesday, January 22, 2019 10:13:00 AM CST January 22, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - One person was detained in connection to a threat made at the Midway Travel Plaza on Highway 40,... More >>
16 hours ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 11:58:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
SUNRISE BEACH - One person died at a high rise at the Lake of the Ozarks Monday morning according to... More >>
17 hours ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 11:27:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - With just over two months left before the April 2 Municipal Election, mayoral candidate Chris Kelly is calling... More >>
23 hours ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 5:30:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - With over 500 districts across the country switching to four day school weeks, there has been an increase... More >>
23 hours ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 5:29:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Back in November, Missourians voted to pass Proposition B, which would increase the minimum wage over the next... More >>
23 hours ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 5:21:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Organizers with the MLK Commission gathered Monday to reflect on the teachings of Martin Luther King Jr. and... More >>
1 day ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 4:14:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - An announcement on who will serve as the city's interim police chief should come around Feb. 1, Interim... More >>
1 day ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 3:05:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Several local businesses are servicing federal employees who are being directly impacted by the partial government shutdown. Lizzi... More >>
1 day ago Monday, January 21 2019 Jan 21, 2019 Monday, January 21, 2019 2:25:00 PM CST January 21, 2019 in News
Columbia, MO
Broken Clouds 41°
5pm 43°
6pm 43°
7pm 41°
8pm 39°