MU study finds severe punishment has negative impact on children for years
COLUMBIA – A team of University of Missouri researchers found children who are severely disciplined as infants have negative behavior up to fifth grade. The study found this to be especially true among African American children.
Severe discipline includes spanking, corporal punishment, yelling, and screaming. Millsap Professor of Diversity and Multicultural Studies Gustavo Carlo conducted the study.
“Our findings show how parents treat their children at a young age, particularly African-American children, significantly impacts their behavior,” Carlo said. “It is very important that parents refrain from physical punishment, as it can have long-lasting impacts. If we want to nurture positive behaviors, all parents should teach a child how to regulate their behaviors early.”
Researchers studied 1,840 mothers and children who were enrolled in the Early Head Start Research and Evaluation Project.
The researchers assessed the children at 15 months, 25 months and again in fifth grade. The study used interviews with mothers, teachers and home visits to complete the study. All of the participants in the study were at or below the poverty level.
All participants were European American or African American. The study found African American children had more aggressive behavior and delinquent behavior in the fifth grade when they received severe punishment by the time they are 15 months old. African American children who received physical punishment were also less likely to exhibit positive behaviors. An example of a positive behavior would be helping other children. There was not a connection found between punishment and negative emotions found for European American children.
"We found that it was a different pattern of relations between early temperament and discipline practices and outcomes depending on the ethnicity of the child," Carlo said. "So for European American kids, we found that the negative emotionality, their temperament seemed to be a stronger predictor of their outcomes later than fifth grade. It seemed to predict or influence their ability to regulate their emotions, and so that's what ultimately predicted their outcomes."