Smart Decision 2014: Amendment 2 involves child sex cases

5 years 2 weeks 5 days ago Friday, October 31 2014 Oct 31, 2014 Friday, October 31, 2014 2:25:00 PM CDT October 31, 2014 in News
By: Shannon O'Brien, KOMU 8 Reporter

COLUMBIA - One issue on the November ballot has attorneys at odds. 

If Missouri voters pass Amendment Two, it would change the state constitution to allow prosecutors to use propensity evidence from past criminal acts against defendants in sex-related cases involving victims under the age of 18. Charged and non-charged criminal acts may be included.

According to Ballotpedia, propensity evidence is, "Evidence that a person has engaged in unlawful behavior in the past." It is used to demonstrate the person is likely to engage in such behaviors again, according to the website. The judge would be able to dismiss the evidence if unfair prejudices outweigh the propensity evidence.

Rep. John McCaherty, R-St. Louis County, sponsored the joint resolution that put Amendment Two on the ballot. He said the need for such an amendment came after constant fall out in child sex cases.

"As adults, we can sit in a court room and describe exactly what happened to us and exactly what someone who abused us or did something to us did," McCaherty said. "A child cannot do that. They do not have the vocabulary to express themselves in a way that people are going to be able to understand what's going on."

A local criminal defense attorney, Chris Slusher, opposes Amendment Two because he said it violates a defendant's rights and changes a long tradition of courts not allowing such evidence in child sex cases. 

"It puts the defendant in the unfair position of having to defend more than just the charged crime but other allegations that could be very old," Slusher said.

The use of such evidence does not violate the U.S. Constitution. It's allowed in Federal courts, along with courts in 30 other states. McCaherty said Missouri is among the most restrictive in terms of using propensity evidence.

Slusher said, "Missouri's amendment is broader than many of those other states allow and the federal courts and I think there are more controls under those other laws than what Missouri has done. Fundamentally, I guess I would say I do disagree with the idea."

Propensity evidence was allowed in child sex cases in Missouri in the past under a revised statute. In a 2005 court case, Ellison v. State, the Missouri Supreme Court ruled against it, stating it was unconstitutional. Prior to the case, the state legislature tried twice to pass legislation on the issue, most recently in 2007. The Missouri Supreme Court struck down both bills as unconstitutional.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Missouri opposes the amendment.

"The Missouri Supreme Court has repeatedly reminded us: in America we are tried only on the crime charged," Executive Director of ACLU of Missouri Jeffrey Mitman said.  "Missourians should avoid the temptation to allow evidence of uncharged crimes to be presented at trial, simply to demonstrate a propensity or tendency to commit a crime."

Boone County's Prosecuting Attorney, Dan Knight, said the amendment is needed because of the inherent nature of child sex crimes. 

"In most instances, these crimes are committed behind closed doors in secret," Knight said. "They are committed by people in positions of trust. Often times those people threaten and intimidate victims so that they do not report these crimes. 

He said it is important for Missouri courts to allow propensity evidence, especially in cases where a child may be too upset to testify. 

But Slusher said allowing propensity evidence creates too many complications for an adequate defense. 

"You are put in a position to defend your client against potentially damaging information that it could be years old, and it is difficult and we [prosecutors] feel it would be a violation of the client's rights," Slusher said.  

The Missouri Senate voted 30-2 to pass the measure as the House approved it by 131-26. 

Voters will see the following language at the ballot Nov. 4, "Shall the Missouri Constitution be amended so that it will be permissible to allow relevant evidence of prior criminal acts to be admissible in prosecutions for crimes of a sexual nature involving a victim under eighteen years of age? If more resources are needed to defend increased prosecutions additional costs to governmental entities could be at least $1.4 million annually, otherwise the fiscal impact is expected to be limited."

(Editor's note: This story has been corrected to clarify vote totals in the House and Senate.)

 

 

Do you in favor or oppose Amendment 2, which would allow prosecutors to use a suspect's criminal history in child sex cases?

More News

Grid
List
COLUMBIA - 6,157 out of 6,987 sexual assault kits went untested in Missouri, the state's SAFE Kit initiative revealed Wednesday.... More >>
46 minutes ago Wednesday, November 20 2019 Nov 20, 2019 Wednesday, November 20, 2019 1:02:00 PM CST November 20, 2019 in News
OSAGE COUNTY - A man on the run since Friday in Maries County was captured Wednesday morning in Osage County.... More >>
57 minutes ago Wednesday, November 20 2019 Nov 20, 2019 Wednesday, November 20, 2019 12:51:00 PM CST November 20, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - A Columbia woman accused of hitting and killing a man on Grindstone Parkway faces a new charge. ... More >>
2 hours ago Wednesday, November 20 2019 Nov 20, 2019 Wednesday, November 20, 2019 11:41:00 AM CST November 20, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA -- The Missouri Job Center will host a job fair on Wednesday at the Daniel Boone Regional Library. ... More >>
10 hours ago Wednesday, November 20 2019 Nov 20, 2019 Wednesday, November 20, 2019 3:45:00 AM CST November 20, 2019 in News
JEFFERSON CITY - Crews are investigating a fire that started in the front room of a house Tuesday evening. ... More >>
16 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 9:37:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Michael Demkowicz had tried everything to quit smoking. The patch. The pill. The gum. Nothing worked —... More >>
17 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 8:35:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - On Tuesday night the search committee to find the new Vice Chancellor for Inclusion, Diversity and Equity held... More >>
18 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 6:58:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - A 911 dispatcher ordered all employees to evacuate the KOMU 8 News building on Highway 63 after a... More >>
19 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 6:26:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - The trial for a man accused in a 2018 deadly New Year's Day Waffle House shooting got underway... More >>
21 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 4:26:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - The Cradle to Career Alliance unveiled its annual community report card at a luncheon Tuesday. The group... More >>
22 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 3:19:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
SWEET SPRINGS - For years, if someone needed emergency medical attention anywhere between Columbia and Kansas City, there's a good... More >>
22 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 3:10:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLE COUNTY - A pedestrian was killed after being struck by a car while attempting to cross U.S. 54 Tuesday.... More >>
23 hours ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 2:25:00 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
ST. LOUIS (AP) — Republican legislators and Republican Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt on Tuesday laid out legislative priorities... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 1:25:55 PM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Police arrested a Columbia man after a car chase in north Columbia Tuesday morning. The chase began... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 11:14:00 AM CST November 19, 2019 in News
LAKE OZARK - A former teacher in the School of the Osage district pleaded guilty to having sexual contact with... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 10:27:00 AM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - A judge ruled Monday that the University of Missouri's rule barring guns from its campuses is constitutional. ... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 8:23:00 AM CST November 19, 2019 in News
COLUMBIA - Randall Siddens, 34, passed away Monday afternoon from injuries sustained in a car crash on Grindstone Parkway in... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 7:14:00 AM CST November 19, 2019 in News
WASHINGTON (AP) — Two top national security aides who listened to President Donald Trump’s call with Ukraine are preparing to... More >>
1 day ago Tuesday, November 19 2019 Nov 19, 2019 Tuesday, November 19, 2019 5:36:46 AM CST November 19, 2019 in News
Columbia, MO
Broken Clouds 66°
2pm 65°
3pm 66°
4pm 63°
5pm 61°