TARGET 8: In final months, Pinnacle was not paying employee's health insurance

1 week 3 days 3 hours ago Wednesday, February 12 2020 Feb 12, 2020 Wednesday, February 12, 2020 7:10:00 PM CST February 12, 2020 in News
By: Daniel Perreault, KOMU 8 Reporter
loading

BOONVILLE - When Pinnacle Regional Hospital in Boonville closed its doors on January 15, its problems were far from over.

At the time, the hospital said it closed because of the "economic hardship of bringing the facility into compliance" with state regulations. 

Former Pinnacle employee Mary Beth Ybarra said she saw the writing on the wall before the closure.

"I knew we wouldn't have any patients on South wing," she said. "So, once I knew the last one was gone in a full 24 hours, I figured, okay, here's where the other shoe is going to drop at."

That same day, two former Pinnacle Regional Hospital nurses filed a class action petition alleging Pinnacle was taking health care premiums out of their paychecks, but not giving that money to Anthem. Anthem would, in turn, provide health insurance for employees. As a result, they were without insurance coverage for months.

According to the lawsuit, Pinnacle acted "without justification, either in a malicious attempt to procure additional monies that it was not entitled to or with reckless disregard for the damage and harm such action would have on Plaintiffs and the Class."

It was not until Ybarra went to a medical appointment elsewhere that she realized she was not covered.

"They had to do a prior authorization through my insurance before they could see me," she said. "They call to tell me that it was showing inactive."

For Ybarra, it did not make sense.

"I'm not sure why I'm inactive, they're taking it out my paycheck every time I get paid," she said. "I called the hospital, and they said it was a glitch in the home office. And then I called Anthem, and they said, 'No, it shows your inactive, and it's been canceled.'"

Vulnerable and liable, Ybarra tried to make sense of the situation. 

"What if I'm walking down the steps and have a heart attack or be at work and have a heart attack?" she said. "Do I just say, 'Oh, well, I'm going to get over this, don't take me anywhere?' I have no insurance."

With or without insurance, some Pinnacle employees needed medical care and medical procedures done. Employees like Ybarra had to pay for it out of their pocket. 

"I just feel sorry for people who, like me, didn't know and had been to the doctor's office or had an X-ray done, and I've got an X-ray bill, a doctor's office bill, lab bills," she said. "They just keep piling up."

Ybarra's story is similar to that of Tiffany Carmichael and Michelle Rice, the two surgical nurses who are plaintiffs in the lawsuit. Both women sought treatment for medical issues at places they thought were covered by their Anthem plan, but they too were told they had no valid insurance.

On January 3, Pinnacle Regional Hospital Employees started to figure it out.

In response, former Pinnacle Chief Financial Officer Dale Farrell sent out an email to all employees.

"We are aware of the insurance coverage issue with Anthem," he wrote. "Please know that we are working tirelessly with Anthem to resolve this communication issue and are confident it will be resolved quickly."

He went on to say, "We had a telephone conference late last evening with Anthem in which we discussed the terms for reinstatement, we are waiting to hear back for final approval from Anthem."

In an email, Anthem spokesperson Scott Golden said on July 31, 2019, "our contract to provide health insurance coverage for Pinnacle was terminated due to nonpayment."

Around that time, Pinnacle was changing its health insurance policy.

"They were paying for all of us, 100% for us and our spouse and kids," Ybarra said. "Then it got to be, I guess, June they said no, we couldn't afford that no more."

Employees then had a choice. They could continue receiving health insurance through the hospital, but the premiums would be taken out of their paychecks.

For those who did take that option, that money never made its way to Anthem.

"I would like to get my money back, I know what I had taken out and my check," she said. "I hope we can figure out what happened with the insurance and either get her money back or at least go back and pay the bills that have now piled up."

Pinnacle's Problems

While it is not clear what exactly happened to the money, it is clear that Pinnacle has had a lot of problems.

The day before the hospital closed, Farrell sent an email to employees telling them the hospital would not pay them as scheduled on January 15.

"The inflow of cash during the holidays was extraordinarily low," he wrote. "However, we are expecting some significant deposits this week and are optimistic paychecks will be available by Friday (January 17)."

Despite closing before the end of that week, employees were paid that Friday. Pinnacle took insurance premiums out of that check, but not the final check employees received on February 1.

Earlier that week, the hospital's laboratory department closed due to regulatory issues. It also stopped accepting direct inpatient admissions, according to the post. 

The hospital also stopped performing surgeries in early January after a state inspection found issues with the HVAC system, according to the Boonville Daily News.

In addition, in just the past year, Pinnacle has been hit with several lawsuits. 

In December, a company that provided temporary staff sued the hospital for nearly $211,000. 

In November, physician services company Premier Specialty Network, sued Pinnacle for alleged nonpayment of $24,000 for rheumatology services.

And in September, laboratory services company Boyce & Bynum received a $92,000 default judgment against Pinnacle after suing for not getting paid.

On top of all of it, last year, the Missouri Division of Employment Security determined that Pinnacle owes $197,000 in contributions, interest, and taxes. It is not clear whether they have paid. 

Legal Tightrope

So, were Pinnacle's actions legal? 

In short, it is complicated. 

Both state and federal law would prevent Pinnacle from taking the insurance money and not giving employees the benefit, MU law professor Sam Halabi said.

"If an employer just collects premiums and then remits them on the employee's behalf, then under those circumstances, the practice may fall within an exemption to federal law, and Missouri law would apply," he said. "If you do anything more than just collect the premiums, if you, to use the legal term “endorse” a particular insurance company or a particular plan, then you can still be determined to fall under the reach of the federal law."

Halabi said there is a real question as to which law applies, since only one can.

"There's little doubt that the hospital made the decision that it made in 2019 understanding applicable federal law," he said. "But it's going to be close to the line whether or not the federal law applies or Missouri state law applies."

In the case of the complaint filed by the two former surgical nurses, whichever court has jurisdiction will have a significant impact on the situation.

Halabi said federal law is more favorable to the hospital in this case because plaintiffs "will only be able to get the coverage that they were denied or the coverage they should have had."

On the flip side, "under the claims that are made and in the pleading that you have in Missouri state court, they could get punitive damages and more generous compensatory damages."

It's not clear where the legal case will go from here.

As for Ybarra, she was able to go back to her old job as a nurse at Riverdale. 

Moving forward, she said it would be hard for her to trust another employer to take out her insurance.

"My dad always told me you have to earn trust back, and trust is the hardest thing to earn back," she said. "I think me having to trust people again like that, it is going to be an issue for me. So I'll probably check somewhere on my own and get my insurance. That way, I know I'm hand delivering it to them."

More News

Grid
List
COLUMBIA - Dozens of MU students gathered to raise money for cancer research Saturday. Mizzou's Relay for Life raised... More >>
3 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 6:41:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
JEFFERSON CITY — Police arrested three people after a Saturday afternoon robbery led to a car chase, according to a... More >>
4 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 5:46:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
JEFFERSON CITY — Missouri voters legalized medical marijuana in 2018, but some lawmakers are worried about what that could... More >>
5 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 4:53:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
ST. LOUIS (AP) — Missouri may have shed its unwanted image as the meth lab capital of the U.S.,... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 4:21:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia is getting a break from winter weather this weekend and many residents are taking advantage of it.... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 4:21:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
REEDS SPRING, Mo. – Students in the Reeds Spring School District will begin a four-day school week next school... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 4:11:55 PM CST February 22, 2020 in A Brighter Tomorrow
COLUMBIA – Several First Ward neighborhood associations hosted a town hall forum Saturday with city council candidates to discuss housing,... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 4:07:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
Black LGBTQ youth are less likely to receive mental health... More >>
6 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 3:51:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in A Brighter Tomorrow
COLUMBIA — In an effort to contain the novel coronavirus, the Chinese government has canceled a number of exams this... More >>
7 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 2:56:57 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA— A Columbia chiropractic office hosted a seminar to educate and empower women Saturday afternoon. The event was part of... More >>
8 hours ago Saturday, February 22 2020 Feb 22, 2020 Saturday, February 22, 2020 2:13:00 PM CST February 22, 2020 in News
MOBERLY - Moberly police officers responded to a domestic assault at 1028 Sinnock Ave., at 2:48 a.m. Friday, February 21,... More >>
23 hours ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 10:45:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - "Honest" and "righteous" are just a couple of words friends used to describe Columbia City Councilman Clyde Ruffin.... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 5:55:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia Water & Light plans to perform water valve repairs at the intersection of North College Avenue and... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 4:57:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia Regional Airport with American Airlines are proposing a new daily nonstop air service to Charlotte, North Carolina... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 4:49:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - The Missouri Department of Economic Development awarded $7.3 million to nonprofit's through its Neighborhood Assistance Program this week.... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 4:25:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
COLUMBIA - Columbia Police arrested a Jefferson City man in connection to an armed robbery on Jan. 7 at the... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 4:23:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
WARDSVILLE - Blair Oaks wrestling sent seven qualifiers to the state championship this weekend in Columbia. Among them is senior... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 3:55:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in Sports
COLUMBIA - The University of Missouri announced a large gift from alumni Friday to support the university's NextGen Precision Health... More >>
1 day ago Friday, February 21 2020 Feb 21, 2020 Friday, February 21, 2020 3:02:00 PM CST February 21, 2020 in News
Columbia, MO
Broken Clouds 42°
11pm 40°
12am 40°
1am 39°
2am 39°